Well, there is one thing of which
I’m entirely sure at this inflection point in history: my 20’s have been one hell of a wild ride. And I find it incredibly peculiar that they
are ending with the same phenomenon with which they started: the massive bursting of a self-created bubble.
In February 2008, I was 20 and in
my very last undergraduate semester at the University of Florida, where I was
about to graduate a year early. I had an
offer letter in hand, including a full-tuition scholarship, to Carnegie Mellon,
in addition to an internship offer from KPMG in Miami. I was taking a relatively light course load,
had a great group of friends in Gainesville, and attended a French conversation
group every Friday at a local café right off University Avenue. I was an Obama supporter, and he was doing
well in the polls. I had come out of the
closet as gay three months earlier in November 2007 and was exploring my first
romantic relationship with another man.
Life was, in other words, idyllic; a giant bubble of bliss which I had
created after a rather miserable youth spent as an outcast in the conservative
rural America of the Florida Panhandle.
And then, over the course of a frantic series of phone calls on February
22nd, I learned that my mom had suddenly and unexpectedly died at
home from a rare kidney condition which she had developed a year earlier. Across the next few months, my entire life
and many of my basic assumptions about it would be completely upended. What
I most vividly recall about that dark, troubling period in my life was the
series of physical feelings which pervaded my daily existence over the first
few weeks. My appetite plummeted, I ran
through my days despite only being able to get 2 or 3 hours of sleep at night,
I entirely lost my desire for sex and my libido, and I awoke each day under a
dark cloud of dread which literally felt heavy, as if I were going through the
day carrying a 75-pound bag on my back.
It took a long time for those sentiments to completely subdue.
Now as a more mature person about
to enter my 30’s, I am waking up each day to the prospect of spending at least
the next four years in Donald Trump’s America – and the physical sensations I
am going through now are 100% identical to the way I felt when my mom died
nearly 10 years ago. On Tuesday night I
probably slept for a grand total of an hour and a half. It doesn’t help that I’ve been getting over a
cold this week, but my appetite and sexual drive are gone. As I watched Hillary give her beautiful
concession speech on Wednesday morning I felt physically ill, to the point
where I had to excuse myself from a conference room at work to openly weep in
the bathroom afterwards. Imagine
that: me, a grown man and a tough, nasty
son of a bitch, openly sobbing in a bathroom at my office. The adult bubble I had created for myself,
living in Manhattan and working in an elite industry, had burst violently. In that respect, my 20’s are ending just as
they begun, and I question where we will begin to go from here.
I.
Nous vivons l’horreur
I want to be very clear to the
folks who are calling those of us who are mourning Hillary’s loss
“babies”: you need to back the fuck off,
and you need to understand why we feel exactly how we do.
It was one year ago that the
terrorist attacks took place in Paris which claimed nearly 150 lives. After that horrific event Marine Le Pen – of
whom I am absolutely no fan and against whom I hope my French friends vote in
their election next year – uttered a phrase which stuck with me and I’m sure
many French folks as well: “Nous vivons l’horreur.” Translated to English, it roughly means “we
are living through horror.” And that
phrase basically describes how many of us feel right now. Indeed, we are living through an American
horror.
Donald Trump ran a campaign that
was rooted in hate, in an inchoate rage which bordered at times on pure
destructive nihilism. In his quest for
electoral power, essentially no segment of the American population was
off-limits as a target of his unbridled rage:
women, ethnic minorities, religious minorities, the mentally disabled,
immigrants, war heroes and veterans like John McCain, Democrats, establishment
Republicans, and on and on. We are
living in horror, and it was a horror to watch this election unfold as it
did. The question, of course, is how we
arrived at such a dark place. And much
of that line of inquiry should be directed squarely at the white working class
voters who just elected Mr. Trump.
II.
To the white working class
I have a perspective on white
working class voters which very few of my fellow blue state liberals share,
particularly those liberals who are of ethnic minority backgrounds.
I understand and would like to
address Donald Trump’s white working class voters in the industrial heartland
and small town America, particularly those whites without a college education,
and most especially the subset of that latter group with socially conservative
values on issues like LGBT rights. Let
me be very clear about how I feel. At
this incredibly painful moment in my life, it would be so easy for me to hate
you, to loathe you, to disparage you, to mock you, to boast about the
superiority of my income or education or wealth or good health in relation to
yours, and on and on. I’m not going to sit here and lie and say that I haven’t
done all of those things – and more – in the past; in fact, I’m not even going
to deny that my subconscious – burning hot as it is with the fires of rage and
indignity – is pushing me to do all of those things at this very moment. But I
will not do any of those things, at least for this moment. And there’s a good reason why: again, I know you, the white working class,
better than you might believe. And as
hurt as I am right now, I understand that you are economically and materially
hurt far, far more than I am.
In fact, the funny thing is that
you and I are cut from basically the same cloth. The per capita income of the rural,
predominantly white working class county I grew up in, Calhoun County, Florida,
is $12,379; my single parent mom never made more than $47,000 per year in her
entire career, and in most years she made barely more than $30,000. My dad wasn’t around and provided basically
no support from the time I turned nine in 1996.
My mom spent years commuting 100 miles round trip each day to cities
like Tallahassee to provide for me growing up; I saw the exhaustion in her face
by the time the end of the week rolled around.
There were short periods in my early youth where my family relied on
food stamps and other forms of public assistance. From 1994 through 2002, I lived in various
trailer parks. Even though I finished
high school as my class Salutatorian with straight ‘A’ grades and standardized
test scores well into the 90th percentiles nationally, I never
applied to any Ivy League or other elite school for undergraduate
admission, because I never imagined that I would be able to afford to attend
one of those places.
And let me be unambiguously
clear: beyond the shitty economics, I
did not enjoy growing up in Calhoun County, Florida because the white working
class was generally unkind to people like me.
My family was an outsider one – my single mom, Marsha, ended up in the
Florida Panhandle in the 1980’s on an internship doing agricultural development
work after she finished her Master’s degree, and she ended up falling in love
with the place. Eventually, she even
ended up being elected as the Mayor of the small town in which I grew up by a
narrow electoral margin; that reflected that her likability and compassion far
surpass the degree to which I am ever likely to develop those attributes in my
adult life. Regardless, being an
outsider family in a socially conservative region like the Florida Panhandle
was not easy, and I – as basically a derivative of Marsha’s personality in a
more modern variant – was even more of an outsider than she ever was. In high school, I was more than once called a
“nigger” and a “faggot.” My mom, a
working professional in many ways cut from the same mold as Hillary Clinton,
was labeled a “transvestite” across her career in the Panhandle. I was told on no small number of occasions
growing up that my family and I should “move back up North”, even though I did
not step foot into the legitimately Northern United States until I was 13 years
old. Those memories still burn me to my
core today. There’s a reason why I, as a
warm weather aficionado, pack my sunglasses and flip flops to fly 6 hours west
to Southern California on vacation, as opposed to booking a much shorter
2.5-hour flight due south to my home state.
That choice is very intentional on my end. The hurt I feel is still very real, and very
raw.
III.
Seeing beyond ZIP codes starting with 0, 1, and
9
So yes, I have extremely pointed
criticism for white working class folks like my former high school classmates
from rural America who just voted a reality television star with no previous
political experience into the most powerful public office in the world. My criticism for my educated peers in coastal
Blue State America, however, is not much more relatively muted. More on that in a moment.
Let’s be clear again, though,
first of all: Hillary Clinton won a
majority of the popular vote. More
Americans voted for Hillary Clinton than for Donald Trump, and that fact makes
me extremely proud of my nation. The
Electoral College is an institution which must be abolished or radically
reformed; in my short 29 years on this earth and as an American citizen, I have
witnessed two Presidents elected – in the 2000 and 2016 elections - who only
won a minority of the actual vote. When
a minority of the population routinely elects the President, that does not describe
a healthy, functioning democracy - it describes South Africa under the white
minority rule of apartheid in 1950. If
nothing else, it means that the United States has become the first nation on
this planet to grant the franchise to empty land.
Hillary was nevertheless a deeply
flawed candidate, for sure. One hundred
years from now, students aspiring to high office will still be reading case
studies about her ethically dubious – and frankly, downright stupid - choices
to continue to accept foreign donations to the Clinton Foundation and to deploy
a private email server while serving as Secretary of State. And in the end, 30 years of harsh and often
unfair public criticism of every single aspect of the Clinton family proved to
be far too formidable of a barrier for her to overcome, particularly when those
criticisms were exacerbated by some of her own unique character flaws. As the son of a professional working single
mother and politician myself, I was deeply saddened – and frankly enraged – to
see Hillary fall into the exact same old gender role traps which trip up so
many qualified, intelligent, ambitious women, when she of all people should
have known better and which she should have known how to avoid. The hurt of this loss stings, it stings me in
a personal and profound way, and it is going to take me some time to fully
recover from it.
But even with all of Hillary’s
flaws, she won a majority of the popular vote – and she should have easily won
this election. And I think a big part of
the reason for her loss lays squarely at the feet of cultural liberals who
cannot comprehend the sentiments of folks who live far removed from coastal and
urban America. Americans in the interior
of this country decided that they could no longer tolerate perceived
second-class citizenship, and I deeply understand their frustration as a person
who spent the first 20 years of my own life as a second-class citizen in many
aspects.
I am a political moderate who has
long been critical of movements like Black Lives Matter and Occupy Wall Street;
rest assured that my criticism of the far left aspects of those movements will
continue after this election. Among all
the diverse objections I have raised regarding the views of those groups, none
has been more prominent and more persistent than my criticism of what I refer
to as the “privilege dialectic.” This is the narrative, rooted deeply in the
critical theory (read: the Marxist
dialectic) prominent on Ivy League and liberal arts campuses, which holds that
people with white skin – and particularly people with both white skin and male
sexual organs – are at the root of all societal inequity, are unambiguously the
beneficiaries of the modern societal order, and must be held to task for the
collective sins of their ancestors, regardless of their actual degree of wealth
and power in society. In order words,
these folks need to be continuously humbled and made to “check their privilege.” This privilege dialectic is particularly
prominent in the ZIP codes of our country which begin with the numbers 0, 1,
and 9; and it is even more particularly prominent among liberals who were born
and raised in one of those ZIP codes.
So, let me be very clear to
Democrats and progressives today: to the
extent that you continue your fanatical embrace of this destructive privilege
dialectic, so will you continue to lose eminently winnable elections. The reason why is rather simple and rather
clear to folks like me: the working
class white people around whom I grew up in the Florida Panhandle and my
summers in Kentucky may hold some views on social issues which I find
objectionable, but they do not enjoy any sort of “privilege” at all based on
their skin color.
You cannot understand the rage which you unleash in these working class folks when you smugly tell them that they enjoy “privilege” from your lofty coastal perches; you cannot understand how these people feel, as they watch all of their dreams and hopes slip away for both them and their children in a globalizing world, when they are being castigated as “privileged” by folks in California with six-figure incomes and degrees in comparative literature from colleges which their own children will never be able to afford. I, as a gay black man, am far more privileged than nearly all of them will ever be because I happened to win the lottery of American have/have-not economics through the tireless efforts of my single mom, my own hard work, and some really good luck. Unlike me, most of my white classmates from high school generally do not travel in business class to spend vacations in Bali or the French Riviera. Unlike me, most of my white classmates from high school do not routinely spend $250 on spa treatments. Unlike me, most of my white classmates from high school do not have a full year worth of emergency savings in the bank and a decent amount stashed away in their health savings account for medical emergencies, if they even have health insurance to begin with. Unlike me, most of my white classmates from high school would be deeply at unease putting on a $1,000 suit and walking into a Fortune 500 corporate boardroom to give a presentation on growth strategy. Like many Americans, I was deeply moved when I read J.D. Vance’s Hillbilly Elegy this summer. Probably unlike many Americans, my emotions were more intense because in that autobiography I read a description of the people around whom I grew up, and I recognized just how blessed I have been. But for the metaphorical grace of God, I could have ended up as one of J.D.’s peers, as could have he. Had I ended up with a conviction for underage drinking on my record; had I not gotten a full-ride scholarship to the University of Florida; had I not been successful in my interviews with ExxonMobil and KPMG as an undergraduate – any of those things, and many more, could have derailed my life before it even had the chance to get started. The pain, exacerbated by the loss of cultural identity and power, being experienced by the white working class right now is a national trauma. It is the problem of all of us, regardless of our skin color.
You cannot understand the rage which you unleash in these working class folks when you smugly tell them that they enjoy “privilege” from your lofty coastal perches; you cannot understand how these people feel, as they watch all of their dreams and hopes slip away for both them and their children in a globalizing world, when they are being castigated as “privileged” by folks in California with six-figure incomes and degrees in comparative literature from colleges which their own children will never be able to afford. I, as a gay black man, am far more privileged than nearly all of them will ever be because I happened to win the lottery of American have/have-not economics through the tireless efforts of my single mom, my own hard work, and some really good luck. Unlike me, most of my white classmates from high school generally do not travel in business class to spend vacations in Bali or the French Riviera. Unlike me, most of my white classmates from high school do not routinely spend $250 on spa treatments. Unlike me, most of my white classmates from high school do not have a full year worth of emergency savings in the bank and a decent amount stashed away in their health savings account for medical emergencies, if they even have health insurance to begin with. Unlike me, most of my white classmates from high school would be deeply at unease putting on a $1,000 suit and walking into a Fortune 500 corporate boardroom to give a presentation on growth strategy. Like many Americans, I was deeply moved when I read J.D. Vance’s Hillbilly Elegy this summer. Probably unlike many Americans, my emotions were more intense because in that autobiography I read a description of the people around whom I grew up, and I recognized just how blessed I have been. But for the metaphorical grace of God, I could have ended up as one of J.D.’s peers, as could have he. Had I ended up with a conviction for underage drinking on my record; had I not gotten a full-ride scholarship to the University of Florida; had I not been successful in my interviews with ExxonMobil and KPMG as an undergraduate – any of those things, and many more, could have derailed my life before it even had the chance to get started. The pain, exacerbated by the loss of cultural identity and power, being experienced by the white working class right now is a national trauma. It is the problem of all of us, regardless of our skin color.
When you, progressive Democrats
on the coast, tell these white people that they are “privileged” and that they
need to repudiate their privilege to make way for folks with a different tone
of skin, you end up alienating the very working class people whom I believe you
aim to help. I grew up around these
people and yes, I know that there are indeed those among them who are deplorable
racist, homophobic bigots who are not redeemable. The great majority of them, however, are
not. And I hope that we will learn that
as a nation, and move forward in an inclusive way which fully recognizes this.
IV.
To President-elect Trump and my Republican
friends
Congratulations, first of all, to
those of you who voted for Trump and who hold Republican ideals. One of the many great beauties of American
democracy is the competition of ideas, and your side won this time around. You now control all three branches of the
Federal government, as well as the vast majority of state governments. You wield an awesome power – similar to what
Democrats wielded back in 2008 – and we will be expecting you to act
judiciously and aggressively with that power to improve the lives of everyday
working class Americans, including those in the white working class who just
propelled you to power.
What I sincerely hope that you
avoid, however, is over-reach. I’ve been
thinking quite a bit this week about what may have happened with the
administration of George W. Bush – campaigning as he did on a theme of
“compassionate conservatism” – had we not witnessed the attacks of September 11
within his first year in office. History
will never know if President Bush might have gone down as one of our most
unifying and impressive leaders in that scenario; instead, he will go down in
history as the man who drove our nation into a state of hyper-partisan
dysfunction which lingers to the present moment (a process started, I might
add, seven years before Bush’s election when Newt Gingrich and his peers took
the reins of power in Congress.) In
whatever event, we know the outcomes of this vicious pattern, and I am hoping
that we break it this time around.
So, let me be very unambiguously
clear to the right-wingers who supported Trump, and who now believe he has a
“mandate” to remake America in the mold of itself from the 1950’s. To the extent that a President Trump attempts
to roll back civil rights and break up families through mass deportation, he
risks inciting nothing less than a second American civil war. I may not agree with some of the incendiary
language deployed by my coastal liberal peers over the last few days, but I am
absolutely united with them in my vision for America’s future. Donald Trump has lost the popular vote to
Hillary Clinton by approximately one million votes. Per exit polls (if we can believe anything
called a “poll” these days), he will be entering office with a 60% disapproval
rating and with a similar percentage of Americans viewing him as wholly unfit
to be Commander-in-Chief, myself among them. Reflecting the rapidly changing demographics
of America, red bastion counties like Orange County, California, Cobb County,
Georgia, and Fort Bend County, Texas all voted for Hillary this year. That archetype of suburban white conservatism
itself, Orange County, voted this year to legalize pot with 51% of the vote. Let that sink in: a majority of voters in Orange County,
California have just voted to legalize pot (perhaps they presciently recognized
a need for it to cope with this election.)
I hope that your side recognizes this; you do not have a mandate to
remake America in some dystopian, white supremacist, Breitbart-esque vision
from Newt Gingrich’s twisted mind. If you
do not understand this, you should fully expect that my senior Senator, Chuck
Schumer, and other congressional Democrats, along with those of us marching in
the streets, will make your life nothing less than a living hell of endless congressional
obstruction, limitless lawsuits, and massive protest over the next two years,
and you will suffer an electoral bloodbath in the 2018 midterm elections. If you govern in an inclusive,
middle-of-the-road manner which empowers all Americans and lifts all boats, you
will have our unlimited support. Count
on it. The choice is yours.
V.
And when
that dawn will come: my love for and
faith in America
Where do we go from here? Believe it or not, I’m actually optimistic,
at least when I frame my thinking, correctly, in the long-term.
First of all, let’s address the
legacy of Barack Obama. President Obama
inherited two mismanaged wars – one of which we should have never been involved
in – an imploding economy which was shedding more than 800,000 jobs per month,
an American auto industry on the brink of extinction, and a nation whose moral
legitimacy around the world was in tatters due to the criminal war misdeeds of
the Bush Administration. He ran on a
message of positivity and hope which drove many of us, myself included, out of
a deep malaise and state of despair in 2008.
Once he entered the Oval Office, he faced nonstop Republican obstruction
of his agenda from day one; let us not forget that his first major bill, the
stimulus, only garnered three Republican votes in the Senate, despite the
aforementioned imploding economy and the fact that Obama’s team refashioned the
stimulus to make it much less Keynesian, much smaller, and much more tax
cut-driven than many of us, myself included, would have preferred. Obama extended the olive branch to the
Republican establishment; in return, they coldly suggested that he dig out his
Kenyan passport and return to his homeland.
I want my white conservative friends who are good-hearted, average folks
to understand how profoundly that hurts people like me. As a black male who went from living in a
trailer park as a kid to being in the top 2.5% of American individual income earners
before turning 30, it has been incredibly hard for me to accept the amount of
residual racism in America; I am deeply committed to the American ideal of
meritocracy, and I have always seen my own life narrative as proving that meritocracy
to be a valid one. I live in a wealthy
majority white neighborhood of Manhattan and most of my friends are white,
after all, as have been all of the men I have dated. Watching the egregious mistreatment of Barack
Obama over the last eight years slowly started to alter my views in this area; Tuesday’s
election results were the final straw which broke the proverbial camel’s back. Around 1 AM on Wednesday morning, for the
first time ever I posted the phrase “Black Lives Matter” on my Facebook wall in
solidarity with that movement. And I
likewise stand in solidarity with Barack Obama, the President who cut the
unemployment rate in half, who doubled the capital market indices, who took out
Osama bin Laden, who saved the American auto industry, who worked to enshrine
equality for LGBT citizens, who reformed healthcare, who reformed Wall Street,
who raised taxes on the wealthy to provide for the poor, who started the long
overdue process of drawing America out of perennial warfare in the Middle East,
and who has sought to constructively engage nations like Cuba and Iran. Thank you, thank you, from the bottom of my
heart President Obama. I have no doubt
that you will go down in history as one of America’s best, most consequential
Presidents. Your soaring approval
ratings during your twilight in office suggest that even today. Your legacy is secure, your legacy is a
brilliant one, and I hope that President-elect Donald Trump understands that
loud and clear. President-elect Trump, as
you crawl bloodied and crippled over the finish line having lost the popular
vote – something Obama won twice – I pray that your 70 years on earth have
given you the wisdom to understand that America did not just hand you a mandate
to undo the progress of the Obama Era.
I can only imagine how
heartbroken Hillary Clinton must be at this moment in time, and I will be
sending her a handwritten thank-you note sometime this week. If you supported her campaign, I strongly
encourage you to do the same. Hillary,
wherever you are this week, I hope you know that you did not let any of us
down. We are so incredibly proud of the
work you did in this campaign, as well as the tremendous, trailblazing career
you have had since your bold speech at Wellesley back in 1969. You are one of my strongest role models, as a
person who aspires to a position of high influence in society by the time I
will be your age 40 years from now. From
the children who get health insurance through SCHIP to the September 11 first
responders whom you helped, your career has been one of incredible positive
influence on our nation. And though you
certainly deserve a vacation at this point and some private time with your
family, I hope that you are not yet done being a public figure. At this pivotal moment in our nation’s
history, we need strong, wise voices like yours more than ever before.
And what of President-elect
Trump? Yes, to the shock of my more
liberal friends I’m sure, I have hope even in this area. We New Yorkers know Donald Trump, and we know
that if nothing else, what he is extraordinarily gifted at – indeed, best in
class at - is being a master of selling bullshit to fools as diamonds, and
America clearly has no shortage of naïve, dimwitted fools in search of those
diamonds. This is how he could convince
droves of ordinary Americans to spend many tens of thousands of dollars to attend
Trump “University” when they would have been far better off getting an
Associate’s degree at their local community college for a fraction of the
cost. So, in short, we have elected a
Bullshitter-in-Chief, and none of us know the road down which he is about to
take us. Like a good management consultant who naturally thinks in three’s, I
see three possible scenarios unfolding in the Trump Administration. The worst case – and I believe, or at least
pray, by far the most unlikely – is that Mr. Trump truly does believe
everything he said on the campaign trail, and is about to attempt to turn
America into Vladimir Putin’s Russia with a Breitbart accent. As I noted earlier, that scenario will result
in nothing short of the second American civil war, and I will happily volunteer
to be one of the soldiers on the front line to defend my precious liberties and
freedoms. The middle ground, perhaps the
most likely scenario, is that we are about to return to the policies of George
W. Bush with a more dysfunctional Federal government, since I fully expect many
dedicated civil servants to resign or retire as opposed to working under the
executive orders of a man they find abhorrent.
That would not be fun but it would be entirely survivable, particularly
because it would result a Democratic tidal wave in the 2018 midterm
elections. Make no mistake, the policies
of George W. Bush were a disaster for the white working class voters who just
propelled Mr. Trump into the land’s highest office. If he and the Ayn Rand-idolizing crackpots in
today’s Republican establishment attempt to take away health insurance from 20
million struggling Americans through a hasty repeal of Obamacare and privatize Social Security, the 2010 midterms will look
mild by comparison to what will happen in 2018.
The best-case scenario – and I do
have some hope it may unfold – would fully validate my assessment of Donald
Trump as the Bullshitter-in-Chief. In
this scenario, Mr. Trump – a lifelong New Yorker and serial philanderer with an
obsession for material wealth and power – simply said whatever he needed to say
to get elected, and he doesn’t believe in a word of it. In this scenario, he is probably waking up
each day right now in pure shock at what our nation has just done, he is awed
by the incredible responsibility the electorate has now placed on his
shoulders, and he is not beholden to any interest groups. If this version of Donald Trump is motivated
by the values which are prevalent in his native New York City, he may end up going
down in history as a transformational, positive President who institutes
reforms which truly do level the playing field for working class Americans
through amending and extending the best parts of the Obama legacy.
Time will tell which Trump
scenario plays out, and as Americans our sacred duty now is to be vigilant, to
love each other, to have deep conversations, and to recommit ourselves to the
survival and the integrity of our nation more so than we ever have before. I’m hopeful that we will do exactly that.
Some of you may have noticed the
general theme of hope which pervades my thinking about the future, and it may
startle you. You may wonder how in the
world I – a gay black atheist and Clinton supporter, living in Manhattan, who
experienced racial hatred growing up in the rural Deep South – could possibly
be hopeful at this moment in time. There
are two reasons underlying my mental state, one driven more by the empirical
reality of American demographics, and another – the far more profound and
important reason – driven by my understanding of our national soul and the
American Dream.
On the wonkish question of
demographics, there can be no doubt:
2016 is likely the very last year that a Presidential candidate will be
able to win the election by solely appealing to one racial group. At some point before 2050, America will
become a nation where no racial group constitutes a majority of the
population. In states such as
California, New Mexico, Texas, and Hawaii that reality has already
arrived. Earlier, I pointed out how
numerous red bastion counties, such as Orange County, California, flipped blue
in this election. Those types of
counties may continue to be hard-fought, but the general direction of their
transformation is clear, and that direction will not be changing. Mr. Trump may squander our taxpayer money
building the second coming of the Maginot Line on our southern border if he
wishes to, but no wall is going to stop the speeding train of American
demographic change. Any political party
which does not recognize and act on this fundamental transformation of our
nation is on the fast track to extinction.
And again, if not for the peculiarities of the Electoral College, we
would be sending Hillary Clinton to the White House right now, despite her
myriad flaws. The Party of Lincoln must
decide if it wants to board this demographic train or get run over by it.
Much more fundamental to the hope
that I feel at this moment, though, is my understanding of the United States of
America, and the overall trajectory of human progress which our country has
always represented. President Obama’s
favorite quote, from Martin Luther King, Jr., notes that “the arc of the moral
universe is long, but it bends toward justice.”
In her beautifully poetic concession speech this week, Hillary Clinton
turned to Biblical scripture (Galatians) to remind us, particularly the young
like me, that we should “not grow weary of doing good, for in good season we
shall reap if we do not give up.” For me
personally, in dark times like this I have always found solace in my favorite
fiction novel, Alan Paton’s Cry, the
Beloved Country. Cry, a story of human redemption, is set
in a South Africa on the verge of instituting apartheid. It recounts the narrative of a black rural
pastor whose son is sentenced to the death penalty for murdering a white
farmer’s son in Johannesburg; as it turns out in a horrible twist, the farmer’s
son was a racial liberal working to end the racial caste system in his country,
while his father begins the novel as an avowed racist. Over the course of the novel the white farmer
and the black pastor get to know each other, and as they both realize that they
have lost their sons, they begin a process of reconciliation. Eventually, the farmer is so moved by his
son’s own work in racial justice that he changes his views. However, the pastor’s son is still sentenced
to die by hanging for having committed the murder. Before dawn on the day that his son is to be
executed, the pastor ventures to a nearby hilltop and begins to reflect. And just as the sun begins to rise in the
distance and his son is to be hanged, the pastor falls to his knees in prayer. Closing the novel at this point, Alan Paton
delivers a final paragraph which still moves me nearly to tears and produces
cold chills each time I read it: “For it is the dawn that has come, as it has
come for a thousand centuries, never failing. But when that dawn will come, of
our emancipation, from the fear of bondage and the bondage of fear, why,
that is a secret.”
As Alan Paton penned Cry in 1948, radical Afrikaners in South
Africa elected D.F. Malan and the avowedly white supremacist National Party;
this party would soon begin implementing systematic apartheid. In that year, a young lawyer by the name of
Nelson Mandela was around my age - 30.
We all know, of course, the greatness that Mr. Mandela would go on to
attain in due time. But at age 30, my
age, Mr. Mandela could have not possibly known what was ahead for him in his
life, and the long, horribly violent road his country was about to go down. He could not possibly know how far South
Africa was from seeing the dawn of its emancipation, nor the instrumental role
he would play in that eventual outcome.
Yet he believed, and he persevered.
He never succumbed to the cynicism, the bitterness, the hatred, and the
recriminations which would doom many sub-Saharan African nations as they began
to gain freedom from European colonialism from 1950 onward. Modern South Africa, a pluralistic and stable
democratic state, is a testament to his character, and to his astonishing
ability to orient himself at any given point in time on history long’s arc of
moral progress.
And here I am now, at the end of
my 20’s and living through this troubling time for my own nation. It would be so easy for me to fixate on the
bookends of this decade in my life given how similar those two bookends
are: the death of my mother then, the
election of Donald Trump now. Both
events left me feeling emotionally empty and physically sick, numb to all
sensations around me. But fortunately, I
know history, and history tells us that fixation on the bookends is a fool’s
choice. For indeed, if I look at what
has happened in-between age 20 and age 29 in my life, what is revealed is an
incredible amount of progress, growth, fun, and happiness. The overall trajectory is clear, and that
trajectory is one that is trending up at a steady pace. When I hit nasty bumps, I take the time to
reflect, dust myself off, and get back up to continue on the path. “Onward and upward”, as I am known to say in
times of both celebration and tragedy.
Our nation will do the same. I
have incredible faith in and love for our nation, the nation which elevated me
from trailer parks in the backwoods as a child to where I am today. America is stronger than any setback which
can be placed in front of us; we Americans know this, and we know it really
damn well. It is a core part of our
identity. It is the American Way and the
American Dream.
Indeed, Hillary, you have it
right - there are more seasons to come and there is more work to do before we
can reap, but we will not lose heart, and we will reap one day.

No comments:
Post a Comment